Monday 26 November 2007

Above the line

My post election gripe is about the iniquity that is "above the line" voting in the Senate. I just don't understand how we allow this to happen. Most people I talk to say: " I would never vote above the line", and yet statistics show that 90% of voters do!
With 46 numbers to fill in below the line on the SA Senate paper it is not surprising that many people choose to opt for just writing one number against the party of their choice. This is great for the major parties, because it means they can prostitute their preferences.
But it disenfranchises small groups and Independents. So well-done Mr X (here)for being victorious against this injustice.
But, why can't we have a mid-way option of still being allowed to vote above the line, but writing as many (or as few) numbers as we like. So why couldn't I vote (for example)
  1. Liberal
  2. Labor
  3. Green
  4. Democrat
  5. DLP
  6. Family First
  7. National
  8. CEP
  9. Sporting Party
  10. Senator on Line
  11. Socialist Alliance
  12. Shooters Party
  13. One Nation
You see the truth is on a long ballot paper there is not only satisfaction in voting for your first preference, but there is also satisfaction in putting one party lower down than another. And why should the Liberal, Family First or Labor party backroom tell me that I should prefer One Nation Ahead of the Shooters Party or vice versa.
Of course it doesn't really matter. I just think the electorate has been duped!

2 comments:

SouthOzBloke said...

Agreed Stephen. There were a few parties I'd never even heard of and I really didn't want someone else to vote on my behalf once I made them my proxy by simply giving them the number one vote.
Great voting card from Germany by the way. Is it for real?

Stephan Clark said...

Yes the voting card is for real. What I find amusing is that you are invited to vote YES or tiny little no.
I think it's a referendum about the annexing of Austria (the Anschluss).
Already one of my friends has told me that they did indeed vote preferentially above the line ion the manner in which I suggested...thus of course casting an informal vote.